Soap Opera Discussion Groups and Forums

Y&R Discussion Group

Topic: Anyone else a fan of The Tudors?


Topic Posted by: Mitch
Date Posted: Tue Jan 17 12:01:57 2012
Additional Comments:

Well, they're not going for historical accuracy with this series, are they?  The last episode on BBC America shows Henry VIII marrying Catherine Howard.  The real Catherine Howard was about 17 at the time.  Henry was almost fifty and weighed around 300 pounds, lol, nothing like Jonathan Rhys Meyers.

Still, it's an enjoyable show.  The production values are great.  I particularly like the costumes and the women's hair.  (Perhaps I should say "wigs".)

The cast is good and there are some new faces.  Or they were new when the show was originally on Showtime.

Anyone else a fan?





Add a MessageGuidelinesTopics ListHomeOther SoapsJava ChatRegistration
Posted by: fitz
Date posted: Mon Jan 23 16:12:56 2012
Message:
I enjoyed the Tudors very much. I'm now following Downton Abbey which is another period piece, with a great ensemble of Brit actors. The costumes are not as lavish as the Tudors, but still nice to look at, and so are the sets.

Respond to this message


Posted by: Ginger G
Date posted: Thu Jan 19 10:01:18 2012
Message:
I loved it, but yeah...not terribly accurate!  I looked up some of the actual history out of curiosity also.  I think I read that they wanted to put Jonathan Rhys-Myers in a fat suit to more accurately portray the appearance of Henry VIII but he said no way.  I'm watching The Borgias on Showtime on Demand now which is similiar to The Tudors.

Replies: (list all replies)

  • I've seen ads for The Borgias. That looks interesting too!...Mitch

    Respond to this message


    Posted by: farmer brown
    Date posted: Wed Jan 18 13:03:12 2012
    Message:
    It's on my long list of things to watch, from Netflix. I recently joined the service, and I no longer have any TV service at all. (I'm saving almost $140 a month -- free Internet in my loft, I ditched the landline and I haven't ever bothered to get TV service).

    So I'm now ordering series and catching up in one fell swoop. "The Tudors" will be on that list.

    Mitch, did you ever see the series "Rome"? It's spectacular. I suspect you'd like it if you haven't watched it.

    Replies: (list all replies)

  • No, I wanted to see Rome but I don't get the premium channel (HBO? Showtime?) and it hasn't shown up on any other channel yet. Maybe soon...Mitch
  • I get it via Netflix (and I do the mail-in method). It's my substitute for TV service. But you can get the one-disc plan for not much a month at all. farmer

    Respond to this message


    Posted by: SnopesQueen
    Date posted: Wed Jan 18 6:44:26 2012
    Message:
    Love love love the show! But there are a LOT of historical inaccuracies, and I made it a habit after every episode to read up on it and find the truth.

    Besides Henry's obesity, he also had that festering leg wound that smelled terrible. It's been a while since I've seen the show but I believe Ann of Cleeves made some reference to him smelling bad. He really would have been quite unappealing.

    Replies: (list all replies)

  • Me, too. I keep saying, that's not how it was, and then look it up...Mitch

    Respond to this message


    Posted by: Cassies grandma
    Date posted: Tue Jan 17 21:18:13 2012
    Message:
    We watched it on Showtime. It was a fun watch. Anything with Henry the 8th has to be good! LOL


    If you like history drama did you catch Hell on Wheels on AMC? It is about the building of the railroad across the west. The last episode for the season was Sunday. If they rerun it I would recommend it.

    Replies: (list all replies)

  • I should watch Hell on Wheels. It sounds like something I'd like...Mitch
  • I would highly recommend Hell On Wheels as well, truly excellent characters. =^..^=

    Respond to this message


    Posted by: lovey
    Date posted: Tue Jan 17 19:45:26 2012
    Message:
    Oh yes! I started watching during Season 2 and finished out the series. If it's on TV, I'll still watch an episode here and there. BBC plays reruns quite often. Even though it wasn't historically accurate, I enjoyed it very much. Henry Cavill is something else!! Can't wait to see him onscreen in the new Superman movie.

    Replies: (list all replies)

  • I wonder how he will compare to Brandon Routh?...Mitch

    Respond to this message


    Posted by: cordero68
    Date posted: Tue Jan 17 17:48:54 2012
    Message:

    In that case, they might want to do a gay version of it :)

    I know what you are talking about, though.  I do not approve of revisionist history television. 

    Replies: (list all replies)

  • LOL, I never knew Mark Smeaton and George Boleyn were 'an item'...Mitch

    Respond to this message


    Posted by: Peridot
    Date posted: Tue Jan 17 16:48:08 2012
    Message:
    What a coincidence, Mitch, I've been watching The Tudors online all week, whenever I get a chance to catch an episode.  I've done a lot of reading about this period of English history and I've been completely hooked.  A note to other history buffs--the story is liberally sprinkled with fantasy.  King Henry is a young, handsome stud with not a hint of corpulence.  The women, with rare exceptions, are soap opera beautiful and hot to trot anytime, anyplace, any which way.  It's almost campy.  Still, I really enjoyed what I saw so far (only one more season to go).  Someone paid a lot of attention to the period costumes, sets, and music, which alone make the series worth viewing.  Most of the actors do a great job inhabiting their characters.  Nice to see someone else who appreciates the series.

    Replies: (list all replies)

  • There's definitely a 'camp' aspect to it...Mitch
  • I was reading up on costumes of the period. It was quite a while back so I can't remember what all I read, but I remember them saying the hats in The Tudors were not accurate to the period at all. SQ

    Respond to this message


    Posted by: Glitter
    Date posted: Tue Jan 17 16:11:46 2012
    Message:
    I've watched this show as I do with a lot I've seen on the BBC. It's amazing how much good tv's on now..you need a spread sheet to keep track. No one does drama better than the BBC..must be that "Shakesphere" trait. (just made that part up..lol)

    Replies: (list all replies)

  • That's true, nobodydoes it better...Mitch
  • I love the BBC and despite the camp, enjoyed the Tudors . The real Henry wasn't easy on the eyes, but JRM is. Loved the costumes and sets. /fitz

    Respond to this message


    Add a MessageGuidelinesTopics ListHomeOther SoapsJava ChatRegistration